Arrested Over Thanksgiving Weekend: When Will They See a Judge?

The call comes at the worst time. It is the night before Thanksgiving, or Christmas Eve, or two in the morning on New Year’s Day. Someone you love is in the Weber County or Davis County jail. The courthouse is dark. Nobody at the jail will tell you much. You want to know how long this lasts.

The short answer: the courts take holidays, but the release process does not. Here is how it works, what you can do tonight, and what to avoid.

What stays open

Utah’s state courts close on Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Day, and New Year’s Day. The Friday after Thanksgiving is not a state court holiday, though calendars are thin and some city justice courts close with their city offices. This season, Christmas and New Year’s both land on Fridays, which makes two more three-day weekends.

Jails run every hour of every day. So does the review that decides whether a person stays in one. Magistrates are on call through weekends and holidays for exactly this purpose.

The first 24 hours

When a person is arrested without a warrant, the officer writes a probable cause statement. Under Rule 9 of the Utah Rules of Criminal Procedure, a magistrate must review it within 24 hours of the arrest. The review is done on paper. The arrested person is not present, and neither is a lawyer.

The magistrate decides two things. First, whether the statement shows probable cause for the arrest. Second, whether the person is released and on what terms. The rule has teeth: if the jail has not received a probable cause finding and a release order within 24 hours of booking, and no extension has been granted, the person must be released on recognizance. For good cause the State can ask for one more 24 hours.

Not everyone waits that long. For many low-level offenses the jail releases people within hours, on a citation or a promise to appear. In DUI cases that often happens once the person is sober and a responsible adult arrives.

What the magistrate can order

Utah rewrote its pretrial law in 2021. Money is no longer the default. The judge must impose the least restrictive conditions that will bring the person back to court and keep others safe. In practice the order is one of these:

  • Release on recognizance. A promise to appear. No money.
  • Release with conditions. Check-ins with pretrial services, no alcohol, no contact with a named person, a monitor.
  • Monetary bail. Cash or a bond, when the judge finds it necessary.
  • Hold. For a narrow set of serious charges, the person stays in custody until a hearing in front of a judge.

Our bail and pretrial release page explains the factors judges weigh. The decision made in the first 24 hours tends to stick, which is why the next hearing matters so much.

Domestic violence arrests work differently

Holiday arrests are disproportionately domestic violence arrests, and those do not end with release. A person arrested for a domestic violence offense is released only under a no-contact condition, and usually cannot return to a shared home. On Thanksgiving weekend that means finding another place to sleep and staying away from the family gathering entirely. Violating the condition is a new crime. Our article on holiday domestic violence charges explains the order and how it can be modified.

If the answer is “held”

If the magistrate sets bail the family cannot pay, or orders a hold, the next step is the first appearance in front of a judge. In-custody defendants are placed on the court’s next available calendar, and charges must be filed promptly for the State to keep holding them. After a Wednesday-night arrest, that first appearance may be Friday or Monday depending on the court.

That hearing is where a lawyer changes the outcome. The magistrate saw only the officer’s statement. At the first appearance the judge can hear the rest: the job, the lease, the children, the years in Utah, the clean record of showing up. We prepare that presentation over the weekend so it is ready when the courtroom opens. If conditions are already set and unworkable, we move to modify them.

What families can do tonight

  1. Confirm where they are. County jails post booking information online. Our Weber County jail release page explains how to find someone and what the charges listed there mean.
  2. Say nothing about the facts on the phone. Jail calls are recorded. Tell them you love them, that a lawyer is coming, and not to talk to anyone about the case.
  3. Tell them to stay silent. No statements to officers. No talking it over with a cellmate. See Miranda rights.
  4. Gather the release facts. Employer name and a supervisor’s number. Proof of address. Who depends on them. Any medical needs or medications. A safe place to stay if they cannot go home.
  5. Hold off on the bondsman. Wait for the release decision. A bond premium does not come back.
  6. Do not contact the other person involved. Not to apologize, not to ask what happened, not to ask them to “drop it.” That call can become a witness-tampering allegation.
  7. Call (801) 627-1110. Our staff answers 24/7, including Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s Day, and every case assessment is reviewed personally by an attorney.

The clocks that do not stop

Getting out of jail is the first problem, not the only one. If the arrest was for DUI, the Driver License Division deadline is 10 calendar days from the arrest, holidays included; see what to do after a DUI arrest. Body-camera video, 911 recordings, and store or doorbell footage are kept for limited periods, and requests to preserve them should go out in the first week. Witnesses who were in town for the holiday go home.

The courts will slow down until January. The work on the case should not. The weeks between a holiday arrest and the first real court date are when evidence is saved, conditions are fixed, and the direction of the case is set.

Frequently Asked Questions

My son was arrested Wednesday night. Will he sit in jail until Monday?
Not without a judge looking at the case. Under Rule 9 of the Utah Rules of Criminal Procedure, a person arrested without a warrant must have a probable cause determination by a magistrate within 24 hours, and that review happens on holidays and weekends. The magistrate decides whether there is a basis to hold him and on what conditions. Many people are released at that point. Those who are not go on the court’s next in-custody calendar.
Are Utah courts open the Friday after Thanksgiving?
The district courts are. Thanksgiving Day is a court holiday; the Friday after is not a state legal holiday, although calendars are light. City and county justice courts keep local schedules, and some close that Friday. The federal court keeps its own schedule. Christmas Day and New Year’s Day both fall on Fridays this season and both are court holidays. Jails, on-call magistrates, and our phones do not close for any of them.
Should I pay a bail bondsman right away?
Find out the release decision first. Since Utah’s 2021 pretrial reform, judges must use the least restrictive conditions that will get a person back to court, and many people are released on their own recognizance with no money at all. A bond premium is not refundable. If a magistrate has set monetary bail, a bond may be the right move, but spend the money after you know the terms, not before.
Can I talk to him about what happened when he calls from jail?
No. Jail calls are recorded, and prosecutors listen to them. Talk about how he is doing, who is picking up the kids, and which lawyer you are calling. Do not ask what happened. Do not let him explain. Do not discuss the other person involved. The same goes for visits and jail messaging. The only private conversation he can have is with his attorney.
He was arrested on a warrant, not a new charge. Is it the same process?
No. A warrant arrest follows the terms the judge wrote on the warrant. Some warrants carry a bail amount that can be posted at any hour. Others say no bail, and he will wait to see the judge who issued it. A warrant from another county can add transport time. A lawyer can often get a warrant hearing set quickly or ask for the warrant to be recalled. See our bench warrant page.
Disclaimer: This article is general information about Utah law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes, penalties, deadlines, and fees change and vary case by case — confirm the specifics that apply to you with a licensed Utah attorney before acting.
Where This Comes Up

Your rights do not change at the county line.

The Fourth and Fifth Amendments and the Utah Constitution apply the same way in every one of these cities. What differs is the agency that stopped you, the judge who will hear the motion, and how that particular bench has ruled before. That local knowledge is the difference between a motion that gets filed and a motion that gets granted.

Weber & Davis · 1st & 2nd District

Our home ground. The office is on Washington Blvd, minutes from the courthouse.

Salt Lake County · 3rd District

Roughly forty minutes down I-15, and a courthouse we are in most weeks.

Utah County & Southern Utah

4th and 5th District. We travel for these, and we say so up front.

If you are not sure what happens next, call (801) 627-1110. Our staff answers 24 hours a day, and every case assessment is reviewed by an attorney.

Contact

Free case analysis.

No obligation. No judgment. Just answers from experienced Utah defense attorneys.

Phone — 24/7
(801) 627-1110Our staff answers 24/7.
Office
3856 Washington BlvdOgden, Utah 84403 · Open 24 hours
Coverage
Statewide UtahAll districts & justice courts · Se Habla Español

Send Us a Message

CONFIDENTIAL · NO OBLIGATION
🔒 CONFIDENTIAL · PROSPECTIVE-CLIENT COMMUNICATION · Privacy Policy